home at The-Reel-McCoy
Movie List Guestbook Reel McCoy Gear Links About
  Buy the movie!  
  Buy the poster!  
poster from The Insider
The Insider
9 out of 109 out of 109 out of 109 out of 109 out of 10
Rated: R
readRead my review
Current Voter Rating: 8.745 (137 votes)
vote on this movie
Other The Insider links (links)

The Insider is definitely one of the best of the year and could very well spurn an Academy Award or two. But regardless of the Oscars, look for this movie to score big in my end-of-the-year awards which are coming at the (you guessed it!) end of the year. The film basically tells the real-life story of the 60 Minutes story on the whistleblower, Jeffrey Wigand, who revealed some of what goes on behind the scenes in this industry of death.

Before I get into the powerful message, the brilliant acting, and the insightfulness of the movie, let me start off with what, to me, is the most original and most shocking aspect of the film. This is a "No Smoking" film. Not once does anyone light up. Simply amazing! I would have to say that I would be hard pressed to name for you another movie where the cigarette is NOT championed as the companion to success, heroism, and/or suave sophistication. In fact, this movie drives against the smoking industry which is as much a story in itself than its own plot. However, perhaps a movie such as this could not be possible if it were not for the whistle-blower (and main character of this film), Jeffrey Wigand, who finally crippled the power of Big Tobacco by bringing its misdeeds into the limelight. Although it was not hinted at here, I guarantee that Big Tobacco has been paying off Hollywood (for years, decades, even more) to glamorize this most STUPID and detrimental past-time. What better way to sell cigarettes than to have people fantasizing that they are just like <Big Name Actor goes here> from the hit movie <Insert any movie except The Insider here> that they just saw over the weekend?

Note: An alert reader named Anthony Jackson wrote me in October of 2005 with this...
when you said this was a "non smoking film" i think you better watch closer. yes it was ment ot be a smoke free film but in two scenes, the interview between lowell bergman and the "terrorist" has a militant in the background quite clearly lighing up a cigerette. another is sitting in a cafe in the street as bergman is being driven through the middle east. they are hard to spot but watch close and youll see.I didnt spot these but my English Teacher did

Another great aspect of this film is in how it reveals not only the fearsome power of an industry giant such as Big Tobacco, but it also shows us the power struggles that go on inside Big Media.

But when you really get down to it, what makes this movie so powerful and so wonderful is that it champions the greatest of themes. Principles, ideals, call it what you will, there is something very passionate and overwhelming when I see someone who believes in something that is bigger than himself. Seeing someone who does not bow down to fear, who risks everything they have in life and hold so dear, all for a cause that they believe cannot be ignored or poisoned by their own selfishness and cowardice. There are just a handful of films like this, and each one has spoken to me its powerful message. This is when seeing a movie becomes not just an escape from everyday life or an exciting vicarious experience, but rather becomes a driving force in getting one to consider his (or her) own ideals and place in life.

Another interesting aspect of the film, to say the least, was in its realism. We, "the people", like to believe that the business of the world is going along smoothly according to plan and that "doing the right thing" always gets rewarded. In reality, however, there is much that goes on behind the scenes that we do not know, and probably don't want to know. This movie also reminds us that often times "doing the right thing" is the most difficult and perilous things that one could do. However, while we are on the subject of reality, it is interesting, and somewhat sad, that this movie chooses to dramatize certain portions of this true story in order to make it more screen-worthy. However, this is something that I can live with, because I don't go to see movies for their historical accuracy (I'll watch Biography or the History Channel for that); I go to see them for their effect upon my thoughts and emotions.

real people, and their portrayers

Dr. Jeffrey Wigand, Russel Crowe, Al Pacino, Lowell Bergman

The realism and dramatization that this movie did have could not have been possible without some purely brilliant acting. First and foremost, there is Al Pacino, who plays the "60 Minutes" producer, Lowell Bergman. He was great not only in his influence on Dr. Wigand, but also on his own struggle to uphold his principles of media honesty. Pacino's performance is superb. His character can be very powerful at times, yet vulnerable in others. It is also great to see him as (more or less) the "good guy" as opposed to some of the downright evil characters that he is more noted for. Another great performance was turned in by Russel Crowe, as Dr. Jeffrey Wigand. He was perfect as a man who made the choice to do something that he:

Don't want to.

What was so profound about Crowe's performance was that he portrayed a man who struggled with this decision every step of the way. His character was also very human, having a few character flaws that allowed this movie to refrain from being another "good vs. evil" flick.

I also enjoyed Christopher Plummer (below) as Mike Wallace (host of "60 Minutes"). His off-screen displays of power contrasting with his smooth on-screen interviews were truly entertaining as well as eye-opening.

picture from The Insider

One of the neatest scenes in the movie was this one (pictured below). Dr. Wigand and Lowell Bergman are discussing the possibility of Wigand appearing on "60 Minutes" to finally blow the lid off of some of the tactics used by Big Tobacco (specifically, Brown & Williamson) to attract and keep their smoking customers. The discussion begins at the table with Wigand and Bergman arguing about the value of doing this. Wigand starts criticizing the media for its warped presentation of reality and how the public only knows what they are presented when, suddenly, the shot below reveals that they are not sitting on chairs, but rather, on their legs! This scene was brilliantly done, showing indeed how our perception of reality is only what we are allowed to focus on by those in control.

picture from The Insider

However, in the end, I have chosen not to bestow upon this film my highest rating due to one thing I feel that was lacking: the music. I believe that this movie could have been made so much more powerful by having an inspiring and haunting score.

thumbs up!This movie is one of the best of the year and is definitely a must-see.

up arrowtop of page

How would you rate the movie The Insider?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

So far, the average rating for The Insider is: 8.745 (137 votes)

up arrowtop of page

Other The Insider links:

Read more reviews from various critics across the Internet

Click heremovielink to see theaters and times for this movie!

Buy the poster! from

up arrowtop of page

Please sign the GUESTBOOK!!

home at The-Reel-McCoyBack to the movie list

up arrowtop of page

There have been 16643 people to visit this page since Sat, Dec 4, 1999. And you are the first person to visit this page today!

The-Reel-McCoy was created and is maintained by Patrick McCoy

Menus by DHTML Lab